Question everything.  Learn the law.  Deeply learn to defend your point of view.  Next, open your mind and become proficient at defending your opponent’s position.  After that, explore alternative perspectives.  Repeat this until you know every possible angle so you are not blindsided by anything.  Then and only then can you proceed with the wisdom to understand what may happen.  

Such analyses form the foundation of legal reasoning.  It is the way law schools teach their pupils to think.  And for all practical purposes, it is the appropriate way to think about any issue, problem, or potential issue or problem in life if you want to have the wisdom to proceed with safety.  The sagacity in this type of thinking is not new or novel; rather, it is found in Proverbs 11:14 and closely repeated in Proverbs 24:6.  

Proverbs 11:14 Where no counsel [is], the people fall: but in the multitude of counsellors [there is] safety.

Having dealt with clients, friends, and a large number of missionaries and pastors for the better part of fifteen years now, there is a failure that stands out: most people can only see a problem from their perspective.  I cannot tell you the number of calls that I have received from individuals seeking advice on a legal matter based on facts that they have provided. Yet, when they receive a sound legal answer, they do only so much as they think is correct.  It matters not to me what an individual does.  Attorneys offer advice.  Clients have the right to follow the advice or not.  That said, an attorney’s job is to see all sides, weigh them against the law, and offer a legally sound solution that keeps the client out of legal trouble or helps them to navigate out of trouble they may already be in.  

All of this is said for one reason: to encourage those pastors who may be reading this to act in a way that brings great safety to their churches.  God’s people are looking to you to steer them spiritually, but part of that steering is acting as a shepherd who leads them, a watchman who protects them, and a counselor who helps them.  

Regarding legal issues, many are ignored in churches until it is too late.  In fact, most calls to attorneys are about what has already happened, not what could happen.  But we are to look to the future – we are to anticipate so we can be prepared.  This is a Biblical principle:  

Proverbs 22:3 A prudent [man] foreseeth the evil, and hideth himself: but the simple pass on, and are punished.

We know clearly, as believers, we are to look out for traps that lead to sin.  Preachers, we preach about electronic devices and how they lead to pornography.  We remind people of the pitfalls of social media and how many divorces can be linked to these online cesspools.  We proclaim the importance of church attendance and how it helps us to be prepared to stand against a sinful society.  You know it is prudent to foresee the potential harms that may come, and you know to prepare so that you are ready to stand when they do.  The question becomes: why, then, do we not take such prudent measures with the church from a legal perspective?  

In this vein, I offer a list of a few areas that are common pitfalls for churches:  

Incorporation.  There are two primary types of churches:  incorporated churches and unincorporated associations.  If you just start a church with a covenant and file nothing with the state, you are still, by default, recognized as an unincorporated association.  The ease of forming an unincorporated association is great, but the liability issues often go unrecognized.  In short, the danger is that if the church were sued, each member could be held jointly and severally liable for any damages if the church is not incorporated.  This could be catastrophic.  Imagine a slip and fall on church property, and now the plaintiff is seeking to take money from every member – how would your members respond?  The response likely would be bad, but it would be much worse if people began to understand that if the church had been incorporated, this would not have happened.  An incorporated church limits the liability that can pass through to the members.  In fact, generally it is only the assets owned by the church that a plaintiff could pursue.  With that liability limited, church insurance would generally be able to mitigate all harm to actual church property or assets.  

Bylaws.  Bylaws are your operating document, and they must be followed.  A church may operate as it desires, with little regard for its bylaws; however, when this occurs, the actions of the church may be challenged and overturned.  This, in turn, may cause a lack of trust in the leadership, bring a great challenge in undoing a particular action, and bring problems that are long-lasting.  That said, many churches are operating with bylaws that are decades old (or older).  When a church wants to act, the bylaws may be so antiquated as to be unhelpful in the current climate.  Thus, a church may have to clean up paperwork before it can do what it wants.  A church should review its bylaws at least every few years to ensure they are being followed, to check for new issues that have come up, and to think through any shortcomings that may be problematic.

Taxes.  Tax issues for churches as tax-exempt entities are numerous.  There are issues such as private inurement (i.e., using church funds for other than tax-exempt purposes, including excessive pay, improper use of restricted donations, improper housing allowance designations, failure to document benevolence distributions, unsubstantiated reimbursements, inappropriate fuel and/or vehicle reimbursements, unrelated business taxable income, and political campaign intervention).  It is beyond the scope of this article to discuss these at length, but every pastor should at least understand these issues. 

Health Insurance.  Health insurance laws are tricky and continually changing.  That said, insuring people under so-called Obamacare can be a potential trap.  It is easy to run afoul of rules that govern the type of plans that are required in such a situation.  If the right plan is not implemented, then healthcare benefits may be taxable.  If the church reimburses employees for Marketplace insurance and the employee takes the tax credit, the church may be subject to a $100 per day penalty.  

Child protection and/or negligent supervision.  One of the major issues that arises more frequently than any of us would like to consider is the abuse of those who are most vulnerable.  The church should have policies in place that adequately protect such people.  Policies may require background checks and well-thought-out procedures that will ensure people are protected in every circumstance.  The church has a duty to exercise care to protect people; if it fails, it is negligent, and such negligence will bring great liability.  

Copyright and Intellectual Property Infringement.  Issues regarding copyright and intellectual property are issues that need to be understood.  In short, someone put in effort to write each song we sing, and they deserve to be paid for their work.  Things like only buying one copy and sharing that copy are stealing.  The church must buy adequate licenses and copies of music, or it may be found liable for such violations.


The list above is illustrative in nature; it is by no means complete.  But the things listed are matters that cross the desks and minds of pastors. We are tempted to think about them, justify our own way of doing things, and simply move on.  But we must realize our role is to lead by example, to demonstrate integrity in all areas, and to be just in all of our dealings.  When we fail, we fail not only personally, but we fail our congregations and, more importantly, our Saviour.  

The wonderful news is all of these issues are able to be worked through, overcome, and handled appropriately.  There are organizations such as the Christian Law Association, books such as the Church and Clergy Tax Guide, and peers all around us who have struggled with similar issues.  You do not have to know it all; you simply have to question what is going on, seek to understand it, and ask for help when you don’t.  

If I can encourage you in one thing as you are considering the best way forward, it is to question everything about it.  Question it and seek counsel to take the right step forward.  Question everything that you think has legal implications, because everything we do has ramifications for our own testimonies, for the people we lead, and above all for the cause of Christ.  

Author